Search

» » Game of Thrones: Das Lied von Eis und Feuer Blackwater (2011– )

Short summary

Confident of victory, Stannis Baratheon's fleet and army arrive at King's Landing and the battle for the city begins. The Lannisters are badly outnumbered but Tyrion has make sensible preparations and strikes a blow. When no one else will lead the troops beyond the city wall, Tyrion decides he will do so himself. Cersei plans for her and her children's future. It appears they are all headed for certain death but help suddenly arrives.

George R.R. Martin wrote Tyrion's sentence "I'll lead the attack" in the script only once. It was Peter Dinklage's idea to say it twice: once quietly to himself and once so all the soldiers could hear.

This is the first episode of the series to take place in a single location (King's Landing) and at the time of its airing, featured the smallest number of main/recurring cast members.

In the early stages of development for season two, the Battle of Blackwater was to take place mostly off-screen for budgetary reasons, with only the scenes of Cersei Lannister and Sansa Stark in Maegor's Holdfast. David Benioff and D.B. Weiss successfully lobbied HBO for an increased budget to film the battle.

This is the second episode written by George R.R. Martin, following on from Game of Thrones: The Pointy End (2011).

The song "The Rains of Castamere" was written about the Lannisters' crushing victory over the rebellious House Reyne of Castamere and House Tarbeck. When House Farman of Faircastle grew truculent, playing the song at Lord Farman's hall was enough to make him reconsider his position.

First time vocals are heard during end credits.

According to the novel, the battle of the Blackwater took place by day.

Pycelle describes the Essence of Nightshade, which he gave Cersei, as "dangerous as it is efficacious". This is the second reference in the show to the writings of John Holbrook Vance, the science fiction author whom George R.R. Martin greatly respects, and the second time Pycelle refers to Mr. Vance, following Game of Thrones: What Is Dead May Never Die (2012). It's no wonder that word (efficacious) made it into the script, as Martin adapted this episode himself.

Highest billing for Charles Dance throughout his time on the show.

The episode won 2 Emmy Awards for Outstanding Sound Mixing for a Comedy or Drama Series (One-Hour) and Outstanding Sound Editing for a Series.

This was Roy Dotrice's final acting role before his death on October 16, 2017 at the age of 94.

This episode was Peter Dinklage's submission in the Supporting Actor in a Drama Series category in the 2012 Emmy Awards- his second nomination for the show.

At the brothel, a prostitute compliments Bronn for his singing voice. Jerome Flynn, the actor who plays Bronn, actually had a career as part of a singing duet, alongside Robson Green. Their biggest success was a UK chart number 1 with a cover version of Unchained Melody.

The episode title refers to the Blackwater Bay, the location where the featured Battle of the Blackwater takes place.

Roy Dotrice plays the pyromancer. He also reads the "A Song of Ice and Fire" novels on Audible.

In order to pull off the effect off the Wildfire, petroleum jelly was fired from catapults into the water, and turned green in post-production as Neil Marshall claimed this would be "the easiest way of doing it".

The soldier who nearly killed Tyrion was Ser Mandon Moore, one of the Kingsguard. According to the novel, his blow horribly disfigured Tyrion's face, scarring and slicing most of his nose. The novels do not reveal who sent Moore to kill Tyrion.

Five of Davos' seven sons participated in the battle - Dale, Allard, Matthos (played by Kerr Logan), Maric and Devan. Devan, who serves as king Stannis' squire, is the only of the five who survived. Davos' youngest sons Stannis (named after the king) and Steffon were safe with their mother Marya at Cape Wrath.

Due to shortage of time and budget, the producers had to condense the scene of the battle: among other changes, the chain was omitted, and "Renly's ghost" was portrayed by Loras Tyrell rather than by his brother Garlan.

According to the novels, it was not Loras Tyrell but his brother Garlan who wore Renly's armor, in order to scare the more ignorant of Stannis' soldiers by making them believe that Renly's ghost came to fight them. When asked, Loras explained that Renly had been taller and broader in the chest than him, so his armor was too loose on Loras, but it suited Garlan well.

User reviews


  • comment
    • Author: Iaiastta
    What a thrill! I don't even know where to start.

    "I hate bells..." Varys said. But viewers do love them. Unlike the other wars that happened in Game Of Thrones, or should had happened (Because they were cut off) This was the first one that was showed completely. This episode (written by George R.R. Martin himself) was the best one yet. I was seating on the edge of my seat and couldn't believe what was going on...

    The whole season has been developing to get here, the war... and boy what a war... I dare to call it a perfect 10.... I won't spoil it, go ahead and watch it!
  • comment
    • Author: Malak
    What an episode . . . The real treat from HBO. The work done by director is awesome. According to me ... best i have seen on TV serial. Blackwater bay was one of the big battles of the books and a complete episode just for this battle was amazing. Game of thrones is setting new standard on small screens.

    A truly justice done to George R R Martin books. I have read all five books of Ice and Fire. And according to me Third book gives damn shocks. Heard that book 3 will be divided into 2 seasons. That means 20 episodes story line will go even more deep. Damn we have to wait for future episodes and also for Winds of winter to release.

    Hats off to you guys.
  • comment
    • Author: blodrayne
    56mins of Spine-Chilling Awesomeness!!! The best episode I've seen yet.. Game of Thrones keeps getting better and better!

    I have the full set of books but after watching 19 episodes, I decided not to read it because it might spoil the story, I'd rather watch the TV series.

    Perfect acting, the details of the war.. Just don't have enough words to express how awesome this episode, and the entire series as a whole was! This episode was a thriller!

    I sure am going to miss it since there is only one more episode left for the season, cant wait for the next season to begin!
  • comment
    • Author: Jugami
    This is easily one of the best episodes in the series - the fact George Martin himself wrote it certainly helped: for example, see how Queen Cersei (Lena Headey), usually whitewashed by the show as mournful and sympathetic, is wonderfully drunken, nasty and on target here.

    Another reason the episode works is FOCUS. Martin's sprawling, complicated saga is a joy to read, but often its page-to-screen adaptation jumps back and forth between story lines given little time to breath. The Blackwater battle provides a solid structure: for once we have a clear view of the chessboard and pieces, with their conflicts, goals and stakes.

    Also, Neil Marshall. The director of The Descent brings his visual flair to both battle scenes and quieter moments - his participation in the show a serendipitous incident (he was a last-minute replacement) fans can be thankful for.

    9/10
  • comment
    • Author: Tcaruieb
    The coward Joffrey flees for the castle and the cunning Tyrion successively leads the defense of the castle from Stannis's army. Out of the blue, Tywin Lannister and the House Tyrell defeat Stannis and save King's Landing.

    "Blackwater" is the best episode of "Games of Throne" so far and the show of Tyrion. His strategy and bravery contrast with the cowardice and arrogance of the cruel and despicable Joffrey. How Tyrion will be rewarded for King's Landing we will see on the next episode. Sansa now has the chance to flee from the castle. My vote is ten.

    Title (Brazil): "Blackwater"
  • comment
    • Author: Carrot
    And besides the action, the CGI is very top notch as well!

    Really one of the best episode I have watched from GoT to date. Even though there isn't much story telling, it felt like the series needed a full on battle for once. I gave it a ten because of the perfect CGI and battle scene's.

    ***Spoilers below, short recap:***

    It starts directly with the silence before the storm. The fleet of Stannis is slowly drifting to the shore and preparing to attack the city, kings landing. Using Wildfire, the major part of the fleet is destroyed, however there are still enough soldiers from storm's end alive to continue the attack.

    Tyrion Lannister has gotten hold of a map of the tunnels below the city, given by Varys.

    They use the tunnels in the end to get behind the attackers, and they successfully kill the storm's end soldiers at the gate. Then, more enemies arrive (a lot more). Luckily Tywin Lannister comes to the rescue.

    It's unclear if Tyrion is dead or mere unconscious. Also unclear if Sandor Clegane took Sansa Stark.
  • comment
    • Author: Grosho
    It's all too easy to compare the climatic battle of the Blackwater to scenes we've seen in the movies: Lord of the Rings, Gladiator, Braveheart and so forth. What makes Blackwater unique, regardless of its lower budget, is its tighter focus on the show's characters and their developments during and as a result of the battle. The action merely serves as a backdrop (whilst also satisfying its blood-thirsty fans) as the conflict doesn't fully begin until about 25 minutes into the episode.

    The focus on King's Landing does wonders to the flow of the episode as a whole. Eliminating the need to bounce around different characters in different locations makes for a more coherent story. The fact that the script is penned by A Clash of Kings author George R.R. Martin fleshes out characters to their maximum potential, after all, who knows Martin's world better than Martin himself? Scenes such as those with Cersei within the Red Keep and the excellent final scene in the throne room seamlessly break up the action and provide a wonderful insight to Cersei's thoughts and Westerosi customs as a whole.

    The acting throughout the hour long spectacle is exemplary, featuring especially outstanding performances from Lena Headey, Peter Dinklage and Rory McCann. Sibel Kekilli, who I feel has struggled more to get a full grasp of her character also puts in her best performance, and actually draws some sympathy to her character which had been lacking thus far.

    Whilst I understand some viewers disappointment of certain omissions from the books, it would be unfair to compare the two storytelling mediums. One of which is limited by finance, the other has no limits with the right imagination. Needless to say I thought the omissions were perfectly acceptable. The wildfire explosion was a suitable replacement for the chain, the latter of which would have looked unbelievable whilst the former provided one of the most spectacular visual imagery I've seen on television. I personally thought the amount of action was more than substantial particularly in light of the intimate character moments aforementioned.

    Providing the climax of Game of Throne's second season, this episode will only disappoint you if you care more for the action set pieces than the tight-knit and gripping story lines. There's no doubt that this is the most visually enhancing and creative television episode I've seen to date, but in reality it's all a masquerade, complimenting high quality dialogue, sublime character development and provides a greater scale of the world which George R.R. Martin has created.
  • comment
    • Author: Gozragore
    No fire, no ice, no Starks. They finally made the wise decision, too late sadly, of stopping constant switches between all arcs. Since The North Remembers I have desperately missed its cosmic editing. Contrary to the past episodes that only looked like a bunch of great scenes hastily joined together Blackwater was a full-blown television movie. Its story was unpredictable and featured many infernal moments. Of course the explosion sequence was jaw dropping, an hypnotic green fireworks, and definitely the one thing we will still remember in months but there were also plenty of other intense scenes. For instance when The Hound suddenly appeared beside Sansa in her bedroom I was convinced he was going to rape her. Instead their face off turned into a wicked homage to the Beauty and the Beast. Tyrion's speech to the soldiers made him grow on us even more and I really hope he'll survive his bloody wound because I'm not ready to let Peter Dinklage go. Game of Thrones needs him ! Losing Ned last season and Sean Bean in the process was painful enough. However I wouldn't blame George R. R. Martin if he had decided again to sacrifice again one of his mortal creatures.

    It leads us to Melisandre because I really expected her to show up and save the day when some of Stannis ships got annihilated. So I suppose we'll have to wait for the finale to witness what the old gods are capable of. Still I absolutely don't regret that magic wasn't part of the battle because it felt realistic, was served by a shockingly dark choreography and overall the production was just surreal ! In fact would it be wrong to compare it to what films like Braveheart and The Lord of the Rings : The Two Towers delivered ? I don't think so. They didn't fight in bright day light but the action couldn't have been gorier. The battle didn't feature elves, fantastic beasts nor mythological elements but it had a dwarf casting fireballs from his ass, a Joffrey who as expected acted like a pussy and brave men giving their life for what they thought was a noble cause ! My only major complain would be Cersei misplaced and way too numerous monologues. I really think they dramatically made the action less percussive when the battle shouldn't have been interrupted by anything. Otherwise it didn't ruin the experience, far from it, and I even suspect the women's side made things a little more vicious.

    Note : This review was first posted on Kritikenstein, my weblog.
  • comment
    • Author: Hallolan
    After waiting a whole week to see this episode, and then after seeing it I have I decided that this episode is the best in the series yet! The GAME OF THRONES is one of the best TV series ever made. I personally don't watch TV in the conventional sense, but I am aware of the contents present in that media, GAME OF THRONES is an A+ in the world of television, where things are not always as artistic as this series. Peter Dinklage is a genius & so are the creators, writers & directors of the series. Lena Headey is awesome in her performance in this episode and so is the rest of the cast. I thank them all for the wonderful moments.

    I will be writing a long, spoiler containing review shortly. Maybe next week after the end of the season, because this series deserves it.

    This series should get an absolute 10 on IMDb.

    W GAME OF THRONES!!!
  • comment
    • Author: Gogal
    I've been getting into Game Of Thrones and I'll say it's worth watching unless you're of the faint of heart or don't like seeing tense political games, murder, deaths of absolutely any character at anytime - including the murder of children and infants and sex acts ranging from incest to rape. With that said I consider this show worth watching especially this episode which is the build-up and payoff to a medieval battle straight out of Blockbusters.

    The big battle that's been building up since Episode 1 of the season will finally come to fruition. Stannis Baratheon, a man who wants to claim the Iron Throne and rule all 7 Kingdoms after being cheated out of it at the end of the last season thanks to this new king, Joffrey. Stannis launches a fleet into King's Landing with a much bigger army then Joffrey's and Tyrion comes up with battle plans to try and win. Meanwhile Cersei and the other women are inside a safe haven, Cersei gets drunk and scares the other women about what will happen if Stannis wins and and Sansa attempts to escape because the guard will kill them if Stannis gets in.

    I love the tension in the non-battle part. Everything there feels like this fight is just as epic and worth the previous 8 episodes and it succeeds. Getting Neill Marshall, director of Dog Soldiers and Centurion on board to do this was a great choice because he does some very good action here as well. If I were to name anything that's really wrong with this and I admit I'm extremely nitpicky is that it should have been the Season finale. I mean, yes - the season finale was very good but I just think this would have been a far better way to finish off the season.

    So I'll say the exact way to watch it would be like the entirety of the show and watch the show in order up until this point. Either way, I've already said to not watch it if you don't like seeing the sorts of things I've described, either way - if you haven't seen this and don't mind seeing the sorts of things I've described in the opening paragraph and you haven't seen it yet... My simple question is, why?
  • comment
    • Author: Pad
    Episode written by novelist George R.R. Martin himself, the script here drips with sarcasm and is crisp as ever delivered by the show's fine actors. The sense of danger and urgency is omnipresent, the dialogues and monologues epic and the battle brutal, strategic and intense, even though like most of Game of Thrones it is purposely poorly lit.

    A great episode following the high level of acting/directing in Alan Taylor's "The Prince of Winterfell" and ending unexpectedly with the entrance of a prominent character.

    Tyrion, Cersei and Catelyn's characters dominate the screen time and shine while the cowardly young king punctuates a few dark moments. Politics, power, friendship, love and warfare intermingle in a delicious night to remember.
  • comment
    • Author: Mot
    WOW is all I can say. Now this is what I call great TV.

    Plot In A Paragraph: Stannis has arrived to take Kings Landing and the Battle Of Blackwater begins.

    Hands down the best episode of "Game Of Thrones" so far. On the whole, this episode really has no low points.

    Sophie Turner really shines in this episode, and she shares some good meaty scenes with Rory McCann (The Hound) Lena Headey (Cersi) and Sibel Kekilli (Shae) Jack Gleeson is fine as Joffrey who's too young and frightened to risk his own life while Stannis is perfectly willing to do so, leading the battle from the front. Stephen Dillane's Stannis comes off really well in this episode and Conleth Hill's Varys always shines,

    But this episode is all about one of my favourite characters and actors in the show Peter Dinklage's Tyrion Lannister. I have often praised his work on this show in my reviews. He won the Emmy for his work in the first season, and he should win another for his work in this episode alone. From the scene with Shae in bed where he talked about his nerves, to his rousing Speech to rally the troops after Joffery had fled to his work on the battlefield. He is simply superb

    In the end, this is the show's finest hour in two seasons, and it's fitting it's the hour written by George R.R. Martin.
  • comment
    • Author: Mr_Mix
    Until now episodes of 'Game of Thrones' have followed multiple plot lines as we see what is happening with various characters in locations around Westeros and across the Narrow Sea; this time the entire episode is dedicated to showing us the Battle of Blackwater Bay. In the early parts of the episode we see the protagonists preparing themselves for the upcoming battle. Some spend the time with loved ones, others enjoy an evening of wine, women and song… most accept that that victory is far from assured; even while they are comforting those they care for. As the battle approaches the tension rises till the action suddenly starts as Tyrion sets fire to the bay and apparently gains the upper hand. The battle is far from won though and Stannis still has enough men to mount a formidable attack against the city. If the Lannisters are to survive Tyrion will have to rally is disheartened troops and lead the counterattack. While the battle rages Cersei and the women shelter in the Red Keep; here she tells Sansa what will happen if Stannis is victorious.

    This is possibly the best episode to date; it might not include any news of many major characters, including some person favourites, but in the excitement of what is happening it doesn't matter. The early part of the episode nicely raises the tension as we are led to believe that the city could fall… and after last season's killing of Ned Stark there was a feeling that another major character could just as easily be killed off. The battle starts in spectacular fashion as the wildfire tears through Stannis's fleet. This is only a starter though; the main course is the battle on the beach outside the city walls. In some of the series bloodiest scenes numerous soldiers are slain. These aren't clean kills; heads are crushed, several men are burnt alive and others are brutally hacked with swords and axes. The cast does a great job; Peter Dinklage is always great as Tyrion but this is his finest hour; his speech to the troops is genuinely stirring… one if fiction's great pre-battle speeches. Lena Headey and Sophie Turner do fine jobs as Cersei and Sansa; their scenes together as they prepare for what might happen are impressive. Overall a really thrilling episode with action so intense it wouldn't be out of place in a big budget Hollywood blockbuster and some fine character development.
  • comment
    • Author: adventure time
    Blackwater is by far an excellent episode for Season 2. It does a nice job continuing the story lines from the previous episodes and the action pieces during the episode are terrific. There are no problems I have for Blackwater.

    The performances are still great, the story/script is still well-written, the dialog is fresh this time around, the pacing is much tighter and doesn't drag, the directing is really good, the music score suits the action moments really well, the editing is sharp, and the scenery is still gorgeous. Also, the character relationships never fails to be interesting. So, overall, a classic episode and a sign that things are getting progressively better. Next episode review, coming right up.
  • comment
    • Author: Thetalen
    In "Blackwater", Game of Thrones' typical style is radically changed, which starts with the fact that the usual handful of locations are narrowed down to only one, King's Landing. This is, of course, serving the purpose of the huge battle at Blackwater bay, which gives the episode its title. The main cast contracts pertinently and only 11 of the usual 25 are left – something that on the other hand enhances the focus on those particular characters. Especially Tyrion, Cersei, and Sansa have more screen time than usual and guest writer George R. R. Martin, author of the show's source material, the "A Song of Ice and Fire" series, includes a multitude of important character information into the cleverly written and grandly acted dialogs. However, it's unlikely the awkward conversations between Queen Regent Cersei and Queen to-be Sansa about the possibility of the latter getting raped by Stannis' troops, nor the entertaining "F—k everything" attitude of our canine friend in the King's Guard, Sandor Clegane, that audiences will remember about this episode. What happens in the last five scene of "Blackwater", with an absolutely stunning twist that will leave your mouth wide open during the whole ending credits, makes it a fan- favorite.

    But first things first: it actually takes the episode quite some time to gain momentum and not one scene in the first quarter of an hour was really something special. The looming fleets of Stannis Baratheon excited me and looked really good, yet I knew that this wasn't nearly the full potential of the show. Slowly but surely, one-time Game of Thrones director Neil Marshall manages to get the right mood on the screen and once Tyrion's sellsword Bronn lets loose of his fiery arrow in the direction of Stannis, the episode's mood varies dramatically. The following wildfire explosion is unbelievable, but the battle isn't over, it has just begun. Before we get to massive bloodshed in front of the Mud Gate, however, there's a cut to Cersei and Sansa, fifty-fifty voluntarily getting drunk in Maegor's Holdfast, where they are separated from the martial outside world.

    And then, in the second half of "Blackwater", an unforgettable battle commences, that is understandably small scale in comparison to cinema blockbusters, but includes umpteen awesome close-combat killings, fantastically realized by director Marshall. Much of the gore scenes, that made the show quite notorious for TV circumstances, are there as well and they are so artistically done that it's impossible to not have fun with it. But it wouldn't be Game of Thrones if the final scene weren't a jaw-dropping surprise. Lena Headey as Cersei is amazing in an extremely emotional finale that alternately shows her and her son Tommen in the Throne Room and Tyrion and Stannis on the battle field. All of this is almost too enthralling to watch and culminates in the arrival of Loras Tyrell. Remember, the audience doesn't know on which side he and his family are on at this point and that makes the scene with him entering the Red Keep one of the best moments in the whole show.

    "Blackwater" is undeniably one of the most rememberable Game of Thrones episodes, even though I personally found the first third to be too slow and also found several inaccuracies and logical flaws (How does Stannis now that Tyrion is responsible for the Wildfire? How can Stannis climb up the latter to King's Landing first of all without anyone of the Lannister's attacking him?). I do think that the hype about this episode is a bit disproportionate, but "Blackwater" is nevertheless one of the show's highlights.
  • comment
    • Author: nailer
    Blackwater is the build up story for the season finale. The battle to take the Lannister's kingdom is taking form. The arrogant King Joffery started the ugly war, and the audience wonders will justice be served for Joffery's beheading of the Stark's prince? The feud between the arrogant/childish 17 year old Joffery and the rational/logical uncle Tyrion builds. The viewer is delight when Tyrion logically makes Joffery look childish. Tyrion builds a logical castle defence. What is Tyrion up to? The other story's hero Rob Stark decides to marry his true love over the arranged marriage. Rob is the true blue, non phony, kind hearted hero (that the audience loves) of the series. The other soap opera sub stories intertwine to create a bubbling stew for season two's finale. I give Blackwater an eight out of ten.
  • comment
    • Author: Silly Dog
    Season 2, episode 9. This episode seemed to fly by quickly - maybe because it's all about the battle at King's Landing and nothing else is involved in the telling. Will Stannis Baratheon and his men win this battle OR will the Lannisters prevail?

    9/10
  • comment
    • Author: Macill
    WAR!

    WAR! WAR! WAR! TO START WITH NIGHTFALL!

    Joffrey needs to die in this war. He's an inbred psychopath. Tyrion is the man. Not quite Jon Snow, but it seems he has established himself as a close second. Especially with his excellent use of wildfire. Stannis is so crazy that it looks like Tyrion is going to go to town on him.

    Cersie is doing her best to make sure Sansa has no interest in incest or her crazy ideals.

    Apparently all bets are off in battle. The hound tells the inbred rat to ef off finally, and the inbred rat shows he was also born without a spine (still remains to be see if that is a genetic defect or if he is just a little girl, more evidence toward the ladder). Tyrion steps up to the plate gloriously, and The Hound gives Sansa a way out, finally. Joffrey's man tries to back stab Tyrion, but his trusted servant saves the day. And a third party comes in last minute and keeps the inbred on the throne for another day...
  • comment
    • Author: Mustard Forgotten
    this is the best episode of the whole series and the second best battle scene I've ever watched, as soon as a big chunk of stannis baratheon's fleet gets ambushed by wildfire and the music kicks in when stannis arrives at king's landing with his remaining soldiers, you get a real adrenaline rush, it's THAT awesome lol, this was a real treat for the fans. I can't wait to see the battle of castle black on season 4, it'll top blackwater I heard, and it'll be drawn out, bloody, gory, intense, brutal, exciting, and adrenaline rushing just like blackwater was :-). season 4 will be insane, it'll have more action, more blood, and more gore than ever before, the fans are in for a real treat since a storm of swords is balls out insane
  • comment
    • Author: Andromajurus
    Awesome everything is awesome this series is unbelievable
  • comment
    • Author: inform
    I think it is the second best battle of this show Peter Dinklage's Speech before the battle was very perfect and well said
  • comment
    • Author: Windforge
    Came to 'Game of Thrones' fairly late in the game and due to being so busy the binge-watching was gradual. Have found myself truly loving the show, very quickly becoming one of my favourites. It totally lives up to the hype and not only does it do the brilliant source material justice (a rarity in television) it is on its own merits one of the finest, most addictive and consistently compelling shows in recent years and quality-wise it puts a lot of films in recent years to shame.

    "Blackwater" for me is Season 2 at its finest and is one of the greatest 'Game of Thrones' episodes, containing everything that makes me in love with the show in the first place. In response to my review title, my personal answer is that it is an extremely strong contender. Everything in relation to the battle is truly spectacular, epic in scope, rich in emotional impact and a non-stop thrill ride, while also having an appropriately uncompromising and far from rose tinted depiction of warfare. Those who say that it is the best battle sequence ever produced for television hit it on the head from personal opinion.

    'Game of Thrones' has always delivered in the acting. "Blackwater" is no exception and would go as far to say that it is one of the show's finest examples. Peter Dinklage is a fan favourite for very good reason and Tyrion continues to be one of the show's most consistently interesting characters. A big shout out also has to go to Lena Headey in her finest hour of the show up to this point, her final scene wrenches the gut.

    Visually, "Blackwater" looks amazing. The scenery is throughout spectacular, the sets are hugely atmospheric and beautiful on the eyes with a real meticulous eye for detail and the costumes suit the characters to a tee. The make-up is beautifully done. The visual effects are some of the best of any television programme and are not overused or abused, the scale, the detail and how they actually have character and soul are better than those in a lot of the big-budget blockbusters. As well the cinematography and editing, which are cinematic quality as well.

    One cannot talk about "Blackwater" without mentioning the thematically, orchestrally and atmospherically multi-layered music scoring and the unforgettable main theme. Again, worthy of a high-budget fantasy/action/drama film.

    It is hard not to be bowled over by the quality of the writing, outstanding isn't a strong enough adjective to describe how good the writing is once again. It always has a natural flow, is layered and thought-provoking and demonstrates a wide range of emotions such as suspenseful tension, poignant pathos and wit. The story is paced beautifully, structured with such nuance and attention to coherence, a high emotional level and is done with intelligence, passion and sensitivity.

    Can't fault the direction either. Nor the writing or development of the characters, most shows could only wish to have characters with this amount of depth and complexity.

    To conclude, truly fantastic. 10/10 Bethany Cox
  • comment
    • Author: Vaua
    I'll try to be short and clear here.

    First, I haven't read any of "...Ice and Fire" books, so I can't really say does this one meet expectations set by original story in "War of the Five Kings". But I was told by a few friends that this act, the Blackwater battle, is supposed to be "huge" and "epic" in every way. So, based on standards set by Hollywood in terms of super-high-budget production, I really expected from this episode to be jaw dropping, and full of "wow" shots. And in my opinion, it failed hardly, and was no epic by any means. Regarding the effects, and the size of battleground itself. From my perspective, of someone who haven't read the books, it looks like few dozens of ships, and few hundreds of men fighting for some small village castle on a sea shore. We are constantly informed by show itself, and characters, that it's about hundreds of ships fleet, and thousands of men fighting, while on screen it doesn't look even close to that proportions. The only thing "spectacular" is that one explosion in wildfire, and that's about everything. Everything after that, most notably the battle in front of walls, is ridiculously small. It's like there's few dozens of soldiers fighting on a 400 square feet ground, with no "epic" feel at all. It's all sized down to few characters, and simply, there's no feel it's an giant thousands-of-men-armies battle going on out there. Somebody compared this to a well known "Lord of the Rings" battle, and I can only say - blah... Not even close to that one, unfortunately. Not to be misunderstood, I shell add that I love this show, and that it's an 9/10 grade show overall, but this concrete episode does not live up to expectations, set by show itself.
  • comment
    • Author: Legionstatic
    Who will stand at the head of all the battlers. This is a great episode with amazing battle scenes. There are close calls, changes of strategy, close quarter beheadings, point, counterpoint, pyrotechnics. It's sort of an invasion of Normandy kind of setting with the battlements, archers firing as the troops, most of them fodder for the attack, fall along the way. There are a series of unanswered questions and the fate of several people is at stake. Mostly, we want to know what is going on with Tyrion who has actually been betrayed though he fought valiantly and saved the king's backside. Who will now sit upon the throne or is it all's well that ends well? We shall see.
  • comment
    • Author: just one girl
    I have to admit, just before watching season 2, I read the book. And until now, I couldn't complain too much. Just a few important parts of the book were left out. And very often, parts of the book were very nicely implemented in the story, without showing them at all.

    But the big battle, the one part of the book I really expected to be the climax of the season, was nothing special at all. They left out half of the fight, changed the story completely, the whole dynamic of the battle, which is awesome in the book, was left out. A battle like any other is the result.

    The worst part is the meaning it all has to the character of Tyrion. In the book he really got into a blood frenzy, killing off anyone who got into his way. Before he finally almost died on the river. But he really saved the whole fight by fighting a really long time on the battlefield.

    In the book the character of Tyrion got suddenly an all new layer to it, which nobody, not even Tyrion was aware of. In the series we get the impression that he tried to be the brave one, and paid pretty quickly for it, without really changing something.

    the 3 stars I gave the episode, are for the whole rest of the episode, which really lives up to the book.

    The most disappointing episode yet, at least I have double motivation now to read the 3rd book....
  • Episode cast overview, first billed only:
    Peter Dinklage Peter Dinklage - Tyrion Lannister
    Lena Headey Lena Headey - Cersei Lannister
    Charles Dance Charles Dance - Tywin Lannister
    Liam Cunningham Liam Cunningham - Davos Seaworth
    Jack Gleeson Jack Gleeson - Joffrey Baratheon
    Sophie Turner Sophie Turner - Sansa Stark
    Rory McCann Rory McCann - Sandor 'The Hound' Clegane
    Stephen Dillane Stephen Dillane - Stannis Baratheon
    Jerome Flynn Jerome Flynn - Bronn
    Conleth Hill Conleth Hill - Lord Varys
    Sibel Kekilli Sibel Kekilli - Shae
    Roy Dotrice Roy Dotrice - Hallyne
    Julian Glover Julian Glover - Grand Maester Pycelle
    Eugene Simon Eugene Simon - Lancel Lannister
    Kerr Logan Kerr Logan - Matthos Seaworth
    All rights reserved © 2017-2024 hd.thomson-multimedia.com