| Episode credited cast: |
 | E.D. Hill | - | Herself - Guest Host |
 | Ira Mehlman | - | Himself - FAIR Spokesman |
 | Angela Alioto | - | Herself - Practicing Catholic |
 | Flora Jessop | - | Herself - Polygamist Activist |
 | Courtney Pilchman | - | Herself - Former Prosecutor |
 | Stacy Schneider | - | Herself - Criminal Defense Attorney |
 | Julie Roginsky | - | Herself - Democratic Strategist |
 | Caroline Heldman | - | Herself - Political Science Professor (as Caroline Heldman Ph.D.) |
 | Douglas Burns | - | Himself - Former Federal Prosecutor |
| Rest of cast listed alphabetically: |
 | Keith Ablow | - | Himself |
 | Pope Benedict XVI | - | Himself (archive footage) |
 | George W. Bush | - | Himself (archive footage) |
 | Laura Bush | - | Herself (archive footage) |
 | Hillary Clinton | - | Herself (archive footage) (as Sen. Hillary Clinton) |
 | Margaret Hoover | - | Herself (segment "He Said, She Said") (archive footage) |