Search

» » An Amish Murder (2013)

Short summary

Sixteen years ago, a series of brutal murders shattered the peaceful farming community of Painters Mill, Ohio. A young Amish girl, Katie Burkholder, survived the terror of the Slaughterhouse Murders. In the aftermath of the killings, the town was left with a sense of fragility, a loss of innocence, and for Katie, the realization that she no longer belonged with the Amish. Now, a wealth of experience later, Kate Burkholder is back. Her Amish roots and big city law enforcement background make her the perfect candidate for Chief of Police. She's certain she's come to terms with her past--until the first body is discovered in a snowy field. Kate vows to stop the killer before he strikes again. But to name him, she would betray both her family and her Amish past and expose a dark secret that could destroy her.

Not the first movie Neve Campbell and Noam Jenkins were in together, both had roles in the (1998's) movie 54.

Based on the novel 'Sworn to Silence' by Linda Castillo

User reviews


  • comment
    • Author: Nenayally
    I actually really enjoyed this movie. Neve gave a lot of depth to the character and did extremely well. Btw.. The movie title on Lifetime is called "An Amish Murder" Its a great story and reminds me of an Ashley Judd thriller or something. Neve is great in this, because she keeps me entertained when she's just sitting there thinking on screen. She doesn't have to say anything to be interesting. And this movie takes place so close to home???? At the end when he was talking about driving back to Columbus, I was like omg.. That's where I'm at. I've been down in the Amish Country quite a few times.. Lost and wondering where I was.. Horses, buggies, tons of farms. I wonder if it was filmed there.

    So anyways.. If you get a chance, watch this movie if you are a Neve Cambell or Lifetime movie fan. Its a good pick and has a happy end to the story, as to all lifetime movies. Makes the day better knowing that there was a happy ending.
  • comment
    • Author: Gio
    An Amish Murder (2013)

    *** 1/2 (out of 4)

    Incredibly good made-for-TV thriller about former Amish woman Kate Kurkholder (Neve Campbell) who left her people only to return years later as a cop in the small town. Her people have turned their back on her but she needs their help when a serial killer appears to have returned to the town killing young girls and a secret from her past might reveal who it is. AN AMISH MURDER actually turned out to be one of the best thrillers I've seen in several years, which is somewhat shocking because a lot of TV movies just don't really do much except try to keep someone entertained for a short time. This film here clearly wanted to do so much more because it gave us a terrific mystery that keeps you guessing, a lot of character development and it also builds up some wonderful tension as everything plays out. I must admit that I thought I had figured out who the killer was by the ten-minute mark but I was completely wrong and all the twists and turns are just so good that one can't help but really be on the edge of their seat as everything plays out. I also thought the film did a good job with the main character's development because we get to see her in her new life but also see what haunts her from her Amish years. I thought the way the film showed the Amish people was quite good and it also managed to make you understand why the family would turn their back on her. There's a second subplot dealing with the woman's relationship with a profiler (Noam Jenkins) who is suffering from his own haunted past. Campbell really turns in one of the best performances of her career because she just adds so much depth to the character. She does a remarkable job showing the various emotions with this character and she's completely believable in the role. Jenkins is also terrific in his role as is C. Thomas Howell who plays the sheriff. Director Stephen Gyllenhaal does a very good job at keeping the film moving at a fast pace and thankfully he really brings a terrific atmosphere as well as some very tense moments. AN AMISH MURDER might have worked even better as a theatrical film since the dark subject matter could have shown more but there's still no question that it's one of the better thrillers in recent years.
  • comment
    • Author: Yozshujind
    When I heard this movie was gonna be made, I was excited because I just wanted to watch Neve Campbell .Then I tried reading the book(Sworn to Silence) before although the movie would have missed many good things. After watching this, it was like people said "Books are better". This movie has cut gruesome material and reduced intensive moment.until a climax at the final sequence recovered these mistakes.

    Nevertheless, Neve's performance has saved this movie. She's convincing as a police chief who was traumatized but she has grown up with strength and intellect to solve the case.

    This movie is not like any typical crime show or Scream (there's a murder but without gore and surprising ending) but it will be much better if it becomes a TV series or has sequels which could focus on the other characters (Glock, T.J, Skid, Mona etc.)
  • comment
    • Author: Zonama
    Only LMN could take a great concept like an Amish murder investigated by a shunned Amish cop and film it like a romantic LMN Christmas special. I guess they only have one way of treating cinematography and only know one style of background music. I kept waiting for a wounded lost war hero to show up. He would then reclaim his lost love. Next scene the marriage in front of the Christmas tree.

    There are famous actors. There are fine performances. Interesting culture clashes.There is such potential for a riveting mystery. In my opinion LMN turned a great concept and story line into romantically filmed pap.
  • comment
    • Author: Konetav
    A former Amish woman returns to the town of her birth as the chief of police in this 2013 film. She is soon caught up in murder, as a serial killer seems to have reappeared after a 15 year hiatus intent on creating further chaos.

    Our lady holds a dark secret, the reason why she left town so unexpectedly, leaving behind her fiancé.

    She faces shunning on behalf of the Amish living there. She soon meets up with someone sent to aid her in the case. Naturally, romance blossoms.

    You will be very much surprised by who the culprit is in these murders. I guess you can say-never say never.
  • comment
    • Author: Bragis
    Like the Harrison Ford movie "Witness" this television murder mystery set in the Amish community is a good watch because the community is so fascinating.

    Neve Campbell (why don't we see more of her than just Scream nowadays?) plays an ex-Amish detective investigating a murder in the Amish town where she grew up. There is a mystery about her departure from the community. Interesting to see her Amish dialog with the members who shun her for leaving.

    Also couple of faults: The solving of the murders in question ends in a rather formula predictable way. Also her detective romantic interest is a bit too plain and the romance isn't convincing. She's got more chemistry with her Amish ex.

    Read they were thinking of turning this into a series if the pilot was a success. I think it would be quite a unique show about a detective in an Amish community though I wonder how much crime there would be in that quaint rural place.
  • comment
    • Author: Gavirgas
    This movie was mostly boring, they left out a lot of important information from the book (including most of the relationship between John and Kate and what happened to John's family plus their drug and alcohol dependencies). They also did not include a few of the murders which might have helped to make this story more interesting. It might have helped if they stayed truer to the book, showed the relationship between Kate and John, showed what happened to John and how he ended up in this town (his supervisor trying to fire him for failing his drug test)and maybe gone into more the back story from the original murders and how they figured out it was the Sheriff who committed the crimes.

    I definitely recommend people read this book though, the series is rather interesting. Skip the movie if you have read the book, it does not do it justice at all.
  • comment
    • Author: Erienan
    I saw this movie a few days after i finished reading the book. I know it's very difficult too get the atmosphere from a book on the screen. The book is from Linda Castillo and I loved it. The film is about 85 minutes and is 35 minutes too short to get the story good covered. The story and cast are OK but it did not got the atmosphere from the book right,the book is darker and the violence is crueler.The rating would be higher because of the violence. Also, just near the end, You know who is the killer and it surprises You. That is how a thriller should be,not knowing for a long time who did it. I watched the movie till the end and had a bit of a hangover. Why a summary of a book when you could make more of it and do more right to the book. That of course, happens a lot ,with books being filmed. I hope you will read the book as well after watching this movie. I think you will agree with me. When you don't know the book and just watch this movie, You still have a raeasonably time,but it could have been better.
  • comment
    • Author: Grari
    We watched this movie on Netflix streaming movies. It was made as a TV movie to run over a two hour time interval and as such has frequent fades to black for TV commercials.

    Neve Campbell is Kate Burkholder coming back to her small home community after being gone some 18 years. We only learn very gradually why she has been gone and why her family shun her. She has returned as Chief of Police. Shades of Margie in "Fargo."

    Only six months back, she and her department are confronted with a gruesome murder, the partially clad body of a young woman is found in a snowy field just a stone's throw off the highway. Kate immediately realizes she was an Amish girl.

    Kate was born and raised Amish but she left that life, therefore by Amish rules she had to be shunned. Even by her brother, Christian Campbell (her real-life brother) as Jacob (yaa-cobb) Burkholder, but they eventually have to work together to solve the crime.

    Another key character is old veteran C. Thomas Howell as elected Sheriff Nathan Detrick.

    This is a small movie with moderate production values but it has an interesting story, if not unique.

    SPOILERS: While investigating another is found dead, this time the young gymnast daughter of the Mayor. Kate manages to piece together a theory of why the serial killer had been inactive in the area for some years, she correctly figured out it was Detrick who had gone to Alaska for a while. Kate gets captured by Detrick, she plans to hang her upside down and bleed her out like all the others, but help arrives just in time.
  • comment
    • Author: Andromathris
    Based on the novel Sworn to Silence by Linda Castillo, this movie was a backdoor pilot for further movies that was never picked up by the Lifetime Channel. And oh yeah - that leads me to the newest streaming service that we subscribe to: the Lifetime Movie Club. And you know my opinion on Lifetime: it's all giallo without the boobs and neon blood. This one even has a black gloved killer scene!

    Originally airing January 6, 2013, this movie is all about Painters Mill, Ohio - not a real Ohio town as they often discuss things happening in Cincinnati, Youngstown and Dayton, all areas of the state that are far apart at the very least - where there's always been a divide between the townspeople and the Amish.

    Katie Burkholder (Neve Campbell) knows all about it. Sixteen years ago, she survived the Slaughterhouse Murders that tore her town apart. As a result, she left her people and became a cop. Now, she's back in town as the chief of police, just in time for a copycat series of murders to begin. Yet Katie has secrets of her own that could destroy both her life and her lost family.

    I watched this entire movie with recognizing Pony Boy himself, C. Thomas Howell. What a bad 80's kid I have grown up to be. Noam Jenkins from the Saw movies is in this as a big city cop, too. So is Linda Kash from Waiting for Guffman and Best in Show.

    The end of this is pretty solid, with some real tension once the real killer is revealed.
  • comment
    • Author: MilsoN
    Others have commented on the film telling the storyline. I will not! I'm angry because the story could have been told much better and might have been a great success.

    I just see the potential of the story behind it and it just did not take me away.

    It contained a lot of cliché's.

    a love story a culprit who was easy to detect by the viewer with a little bit of experience.

    But what most bothered me as the amateuristic scenario suddenly the main character gets fired, no build up suddenly the main character starts to get into a relation not really professional.

    Suddenly the side kick showed up (how did he know where she was) when she was digging.

    etc etc

    I thought professionals worked in Hollywood. this looks like good school project.

    I'm angry because the story could have been told much better and might have been a great success.
  • comment
    • Author: Frdi
    Not bad for a derivative work: the summary says it all. What do you get when you cross "Witness" with "Fargo" on Lifetime? I figured it out the second time I saw the culprit; so it is not really that much of a mystery. I did like her relationship to the Amish community, and I knew that the profiler would absolutely have to be overcome his phobia at the physical climax, but that's just the creaky dramaturgy. (I would really go for 2 1/2 * but that was not a choice.) It is acceptable on TV, but it is a good thing I did not have to spend multiplex prices to see it. It feels like a pilot for a series about a female ex-Amish police chief in a rural Ohio town.
  • Cast overview, first billed only:
    Neve Campbell Neve Campbell - Kate Burkholder
    Noam Jenkins Noam Jenkins - John Tomasetti
    Jilon VanOver Jilon VanOver - Lucas Holst
    Christian Campbell Christian Campbell - Jacob Burkholder
    Irone Singleton Irone Singleton - Glock Nichols
    Alec McClure Alec McClure - T.J. Banks
    Linda Kash Linda Kash - Mona
    Mary Krohnert Mary Krohnert - Sarah Burkholder
    C. Thomas Howell C. Thomas Howell - Nathan Detrick
    R.D. Reid R.D. Reid - Chuck 'Skid' Skidmore
    Patrick Garrow Patrick Garrow - Lieutenant Anderson
    Richard Blackburn Richard Blackburn - Doc Coblenz
    Duane Murray Duane Murray - Mayor Auggie Brock
    Billy MacLellan Billy MacLellan - Daniel Lapp
    Brad Borbridge Brad Borbridge - Mr. Waring
    All rights reserved © 2017-2024 hd.thomson-multimedia.com