Search

» » Западное крыло The Debate (1999–2006)

Short summary

In an episode originally broadcast live (there are two versions, one for the Eastern and Central time zones; one for the Pacific time zone), Santos and Vinnick square off in a debate with TV newsman Forrest Sawyer (as himself) moderating. Halfway through the debate, Santos departs from the "script" and begins delivering statements while pacing the stage; Vinnick joins in. Other cast members appear briefly in backstage film segments, and Ellen DeGeneres hosts (also on film) from an adjacent sound stage. Alan Alda (Vinnick), an accomplished stage actor, seems much more comfortable with the live format than Jimmy Smits (Santos) who blows several lines during the East Coast hour.

The Debate was advertised as a "live presidential debate" and was actually telecast live twice, once for the East and West coasts, with limited commercial interruption. It was also one of the few times actors were allowed to go "off script."

This is the only episode of the series in which none of the original main cast appeared.

The heckler in the audience who calls Vinick a liar is executive producer Christopher Misiano.

The episode won an Emmy Award for Outstanding Multi-Camera Sound Mixing for a Series or Special.

Congressman Santos's defense of the term "liberal" is a paraphrase of Kennedy's 1960 NY acceptance speech.

The episode was shot "Live" so the TV-debate would have the same live debate "flavor" that the real debates have. This is most notable in the quality of the image on screen, which is more crisp, than the image of the other episodes, which is actually shot on 35mm film

Matt Santos mentions a quote he made about having voted for a bill before he voted against it. This is a reference to John Kerry's infamous gaffe in which he commented that he voted for a spending bill before he voted against it.

This is not the first time Alan Alda has ad-libbed as a TV character. When he played Hawkeye Pierce on Чёртова служба в гoспитале МЭШ (1972), an episode called Чёртова служба в гoспитале МЭШ: The Interview (1976) showed the characters being interviewed by a war correspondent. The questions were scripted, but most of the replies were spontaneous.

"Previously on the West Wing" spoken by C.J. (Allison Janney).

Although the debate episode was done twice, only the West Coast version appears on the Season 7 DVD, and the parts with Ellen DeGeneres were edited out.

This episode contains the fewest main cast members of any episode at two. Before this episode, Западное крыло: The Long Goodbye (2003) and Западное крыло: Message of the Week (2005) have been tied with three. It also has the smallest overall cast for any episode at seven.

User reviews


  • comment
    • Author: Tygrafym
    This episode is original, perceptive, and accurate. It is remarkable how each side portray their viewpoints on different political issues – health care, education, dependency on foreign oil, etc. The West Wing has always been a great show examining a vast array of political issues – while remaining fair to both Democrats and Republicans.

    This episode is not like conventional episodes. It is literally a passionate debate between two sides. While watching the debate, I felt very engaged, it reminded of the first debate between President Obama and Senator McCain in the sense that an underdog is able to stand toe-to-toe with his competitor and debate with authority.

    I highly recommend this episode because it felt like the old West Wing episodes that only Aaron Sorkin could deliver. Like many people that love the West Wing, I will agree that the show took a turn towards dull and uninspiring after Aaron Sorkin stopped writing, but this episode restored itself confirming that it is the best political show television has ever seen.
  • Episode complete credited cast:
    Janeane Garofalo Janeane Garofalo - Louise Thornton
    Ron Silver Ron Silver - Bruno Gianelli
    Teri Polo Teri Polo - Helen Santos
    Patricia Richardson Patricia Richardson - Sheila Brooks
    Forrest Sawyer Forrest Sawyer - Himself
    Alan Alda Alan Alda - Senator Arnold Vinick
    Kristin Chenoweth Kristin Chenoweth - Annabeth Schott (credit only)
    Allison Janney Allison Janney - C.J. Cregg (credit only)
    Mary McCormack Mary McCormack - Kate Harper (credit only)
    John Spencer John Spencer - Leo McGarry (credit only)
    Bradley Whitford Bradley Whitford - Josh Lyman (credit only)
    Jimmy Smits Jimmy Smits - Matthew Santos
    Martin Sheen Martin Sheen - President Josiah 'Jed' Bartlet (credit only)
    All rights reserved © 2017-2024 hd.thomson-multimedia.com