| Episode credited cast: |
 | Manny Acta | - | Himself - New York Mets Third Base Coach |
 | Neil Allen | - | Himself - New York Yankees Bullpen Coach |
 | Sandy Alomar | - | Himself - New York Mets First Base Coach |
 | Marlon Anderson | - | Himself - New York Mets Second Baseman |
 | Carlos Beltran | - | Himself - New York Mets Center Fielder |
 | Kris Benson | - | Himself - New York Mets Pitcher |
 | Mike Cameron | - | Himself - New York Mets Right Fielder |
 | Robinson Cano | - | Himself - New York Yankees Second Baseman |
 | Ramon Castro | - | Himself - New York Mets Catcher |
 | Guy Conti | - | Himself - New York Mets Bullpen Coach |
 | Rick Down | - | Himself - New York Mets Hitting Coach |
 | John Flaherty | - | Himself - New York Yankees Catcher |
 | Cliff Floyd | - | Himself - New York Mets Left Fielder |
 | Jason Giambi | - | Himself - New York Yankees First Baseman |
 | Joe Girardi | - | Himself - New York Yankees Bench Coach |