Search

» » The Breaking Point (1924)

Short summary

A print of this film survives in the Library of Congress.

User reviews


  • comment
    • Author: Alianyau
    'The Breaking Point' is a great title for a suspense movie; unfortunately, this particular movie isn't a suspenser, and it's not even an especially good movie.

    Matt Moore, sporting dapper clothes and an annoying little moustache (I think he stole it from Warner Oland), has something or other to do with a murder in Wyoming ... but he can't say precisely what, because shortly afterward he conveniently develops amnesia. (Perhaps a bit TOO conveniently.) He heads for points east, and lands up in the care of a kindly physician who bears the unfortunate name David Livingstone. (I kept waiting for one of the other characters to say 'Doctor Livingstone, I presume.') Dr Livingstone is dating the winsome Patsy Ruth Miller, so Moore shows his ingratitude by being attracted to her as well. At this point, the movie feels more like soap opera than whodunnit.

    Ten years after the murder, along comes a newspaper reporter named Bassett, who is a real bloodhound. Bassett by name and basset by nature, this dirty Bassett starts nosey-parkering into Moore's past, trying to tie him to the unsolved crime.

    Nita Naldi, playing the reason for the murder -- a crime of passion, of course -- sports a truly weird chignon coiffure, along with elaborate make-up and surprisingly thick eyebrows. Annoyingly, her character is lumbered in the intertitles with the surname "Carlysle": why couldn't it be spelt Carlisle or (even better) Carlyle? I found myself pondering mysteries like this, because the 'mystery' elements in this movie aren't very gripping. I also found myself thinking that Naldi's eyebrows ought to elope with Moore's moustache, in a menage a trois.

    'The Breaking Point' has very little suspense, and too much mystery in the sense of being baffling rather than being a whodunnit. There are actually a few good noir touches here, two decades before the film-noir genre was formalised. But, apart from the superb photography by James Wong Howe, and some decent acting by Patsy Ruth Miller (whom I met once), I found little to captivate me. Director Herbert Brenon always did his best work in stories with fantasy elements or showbiz glitz, and this movie has neither. I rate this one just 4 out of 10.
  • Cast overview:
    Nita Naldi Nita Naldi - Beverly Carlysle
    Patsy Ruth Miller Patsy Ruth Miller - Elizabeth Wheeler
    George Fawcett George Fawcett - Dr. David Livingstone
    Matt Moore Matt Moore - Judson Clark
    John Merkyl John Merkyl - William Lucas
    Theodore von Eltz Theodore von Eltz - Fred Gregory (as Theodor Von Eltz)
    Edythe Chapman Edythe Chapman - Lucy Livingstone
    Cyril Ring Cyril Ring - Louis Bassett
    Westcott Clarke Westcott Clarke - Sheriff Wilkins (as W.B. Westcott)
    Edward Kipling Edward Kipling - Joe
    Milton Brown Milton Brown - Donaldson (as Milt Brown)
    Charles A. Stevenson Charles A. Stevenson - Harrison Wheeler
    Naida Faro Naida Faro - Minnie
    All rights reserved © 2017-2024 hd.thomson-multimedia.com