Search

» » The Twilight Zone The Silence (1959–1964)

Short summary

Jamie Tennyson is an overly talkative member of a private men's club. He is challenged by fellow member Col. Archie Taylor to keep his mouth shut for one year. Should he do so, he would win $500,000. Taylor dislikes Tennyson and if nothing else, finds this a way to get a bit of peace and quiet at the club. Tennyson will live in a room in the club, under observation and will communicate in writing only. As the months go by, Taylor begins to worry that Tennyson may just succeed. He can't believe Tennyson's will but neither party proves to be completely honorable.

Franchot Tone filmed the club sequences in the early part of production before suffering a facial injury (Liam Sullivan claimed that he had fallen off a terrace to a driveway while picking a flower for a girlfriend; Rod Serling said that a jealous romantic rival had attacked him). Even though the left side of his face was swollen, it was decided not to hire a different actor and re-shoot the previously filmed scenes, but to film him with only his right side exposed to the camera. Interestingly, it caused Tone's character to be denied eye contact while mocking Sullivan's, which made his character more sinister and added an extra dimension of emotion to the plot.

One of four Unglaubliche Geschichten (1959) episodes that, notably, contains no science fiction or fantasy elements.

The plot of a man accepting a bet that he could remain isolated (being unable to speak rather than having no direct human contact) for a year and the desperation of the one waiting for the bet to finish, was inspired by Anton Chekhov's short story "The Bet".

This episode takes place from June 2, 1961 to June 3, 1962.

User reviews


  • comment
    • Author: Wen
    In an elitist men´s club, the arrogant Colonel Archie Taylor is irritated with the talkative fellow member Jamie Tennyson. He proposes a US$ 500,000 wager to Jamie to keep him in silence for one year. Jamie accepts the bet since he likes to indulge his wife and has debts to pay; so he is locked in a class walled room built in the club and all his communication is made in writing. Who will win the wager?

    "The Silence" is a dark episode of "The Twilight Zone", with a sharp criticism to gamble. In the end both players lose the prize, one more than the other. My vote is eight.

    Title (Brazil): "O Silêncio" ("The Silence")
  • comment
    • Author: Gogul
    "The Silence" is one of the few entries in the Twilight Zone series that is grounded in reality and takes place in the "here and now." A stuffy and exclusive Upper-Class Gentleman's club is the setting for an outrageous and mean-spirited wager between two men who loathe each other. Franchot Tone (Colonel Taylor) bets his loud-mouthed obnoxious adversary Tennyson (Liam Sullivan) that he can't remain silent for one whole year. The wager is for $500,000, a huge sum for this time period. Tennyson is locked in one of the rooms in the basement of the club for safe-keeping during his ordeal and continually watched for the duration of the bet. As the months roll on, Colonel Taylor's true nasty personality reveals itself and the audience soon realizes that he hasn't the money to cover the wager. When the year passes and Tennyson emerges from his self-imposed captivity, he and everyone else finds out the awful truth about Taylor's disreputable deception. Yet although Tennyson has technically won the bet and retained some of his honor, he is still unable to speak, for he has a secret too. In horror, he reveals to all (through pen and paper) that he had his vocal cords permanently severed in order to win the money.

    Performances are all top-notch in this episode; both Franchot Tone and Liam Sullivan play their roles to the hilt and the stars are perfectly cast. Jonathan Harris ("Lost in Space") is also outstanding as Tone's well-intentioned lawyer whose advice to his client goes unheeded. The episode is directed by the sure-handed veteran Boris Sagal and written by Twilight Zone creator, Rod Serling.
  • comment
    • Author: Drelajurus
    Two rapscallions wage a bet for $500,000 dollars on the line. A bet of silence, if you will. The chatterbox Jamie Tennyson (Liam Sullivan; Star Trek episode, Plato's Stepchildren), who drones on and on with older gents (particularly annoyed and wanting to get away from him but unable to do so) at a men's club has gotten on the very last nerve of Archie Taylor (Franchot Tone), a regular if just for his family name and "fine breeding" (his words). Taylor (and the other men who congregate at this meeting place for an "aging retired elite of affluence") just wants Tennyson to shut up. To just quit talking. The men around him are delighted with the wager where Archie offers half a million to Tennyson if he can go a whole year without saying a word. The idea that they didn't have to listen to him hammer away about what he could do with a loan (a substantial one he muses aloud hoping to get a loan from someone gullible enough to expect he'd be successful, which no one is silly enough to answer in his favor), and his opinions on people he "meets at the market" (stock market) is a sweet savor to their ears.

    But as Archie's concerned lawyer (played by Lost in Space's Jonathan Harris) approaches him troubled by this whole affair, the prideful, pompous "man of integrity and honorable social standing" shows the kind of menace he truly is. Archie devises this masterplan where a room downstairs in the men's club houses Tennyson is encased in glass with microphones and cameras watching and listening to see if he'd talk. So a year he endures the silence…with a price. Talk about a guy that gets it multiple ways: you can't help but sympathize with Tennyson. Archie's repeated attempts to use Tennyson's "possibly promiscuous" wife to break him (the true backstory of Tone's face damage adds notoriety and actually is considered by TZ scholars to be a benefit to the episode as that one side only visible provided the actor with this added bit of sinister, deviousness, and serpent-in-the-grass sneakiness) particularly is rather unpleasant and wholly distasteful. A big scene is the set-up, in my opinion. Archie diminishing Tennyson's character, insulting his personality, speaking candidly about how his voice causes him to wince and that his mere presence is a nuisance almost immediately earns the derided youngster some sympathy. Archie never comes off less that an arrogant, entitled morally dubious scoundrel carrying on a charade that fooled all of the men in his inner circle. Of course, on first glance, Tennyson has this bravado and carries himself also as someone deserved to be within the high class of a society of privilege. However, a key scene between Sullivan and Harris opens our eyes to the fact that he is indeed broke and not of a charmed life as Archie had mightily pointed out to all who would listen…he had squandered his inheritance and financial support on bad choices in the market, and with a wife who "visits Tiffanys as much as others do a grocery store", that certainly didn't help.

    But the twist is what makes The Silence so devastating and stinging. Be careful who you wager with because it could come back to truly turn on you badly. First off, Archie doesn't provide the money beforehand. He claims that Tennyson will have to trust his *reputation.* Second, Archie continues to use manipulation and defamation brazenly to get Tennyson to crack. So when the two face each other at the end, and Archie is forced to reveal his true situation, Tennyson's fate perhaps isn't a surprise. His reason for the silence, however, is a stunner. It is everything TZ represents in regards to a twist of fate that often leaves the main character in a rotten predicament. I think, for not featuring anything supernatural, fantastical, or sci-fi related, The Silence is a real gem. I think it is underrated and worth taking a look at if you haven't yet. Tone is a game antagonist and Sullivan equal as his desperate foil. Harris as the voice of reason is rightfully grim and dead serious, but Tone's superiority complex will simply not listen.
  • comment
    • Author: Kecq
    The Silence, like many Twilight Zone episodes, has a good twist at the end that lands it solidly in the realm of the supernatural, but unfortunately (and also like a lot of other twilight zone episodes), that supernaturalness is reached more because of the main character's astonishing stupidity than anything really supernatural. Not that there is anything wrong with that. I appreciate wildly different behavior from what I would expect from myself in a show like the twilight zone infinitely more than in, for example, modern Hollywood horror movies, so The Silence ranks as one of the more entertaining episodes to me. Regardless of why the twist is as shocking as it is, the story is undeniably absorbing.

    In a hugely exclusive men's club, one elderly gentleman is enormously disturbed by one of the members' constant, constant babbling. It's clear that all of the men are more than a little irritated by this one man and his unending, horizonless barrage of nonstop speaking, but one of them much more than anyone else. So much so, in fact, that he bets the man $500,000 that he can't keep his mouth shut for a year. One IMDb user states that this was a huge amount of money for the time period. I'm going to go ahead and suggest that this might be an enormous amount of money for ANY time period. And for ANY bet.

    It reminds me of a particular sentence from one of my favorite books (Mark Twain's "A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court") that, for some reason, managed to stay with me. The main character is describing a rather unfortunate relationship he is in with an intensely uneducated woman who never seems to stop talking. One day he wanted to say something to her (generally he would just let her talk and let his mind wander), so he says something like, "One afternoon I interrupted her in the middle of a sentence that she had begun that morning..." You get the idea. This guy is one of those people.

    I hear that the main actor suffered an injury that prevented him being filmed in anything other than profile from the right. This sounds like gossip to me, probably generated by an unusual filming style, although not exactly impossible, I suppose.

    What I love about this episode is how confident at the beginning the man who suggests the wager is. He is absolutely certain that this man won't be able to be quiet for a year, saying that he might last several weeks, maybe even a couple months, but the idea that such a man could last a full year was preposterous to him (and maybe to us).

    As the end of the bet gets closer, the man gets increasingly desperate, even offering the guy $1,000 and then $5,000 to just quit the bet and walk away, even though there was only a couple months or weeks left by then.

    There is one thing though, I was curious about what kind of a guy would not only accept this kind of bet, but what kind of guy had the free time to drop everything in his life and lock himself in a glass room for a year. Didn't he have a job? The exclusiveness of the gentlemen's club suggests that many of its patrons were independently wealthy, but if that was the case, why accept the bet in the first place?

    At any rate, the show makes a great comment on upper class superficiality and the lengths people will go to in order to make money and, even more, boast their wealth and social status. Both, Serling says, can lead to disaster...
  • comment
    • Author: Orevise
    Franchot Tone plays Col. Archie Taylor, respected member of a private men's club where he has become gradually fed up with younger member Jamie Tennyson(played by Liam Sullivan) who wont stop talking and bragging. One day, Archie hits upon the idea to wager Jamie $500,000 if he will agree to remain silent for one year, and live in a specially prepared dome in the club basement. Tennyson agrees(he needs the money badly) but Taylor becomes concerned and surprised at how determined the young man is, but nothing prepares them for the ultimate shock at the end... Unusual episode is the most atypical of the series, but final twist is indeed a jaw dropper, and superbly put across.
  • comment
    • Author: Zugar
    You have to watch this one before you know the twist at the end because that is mostly what this story is about. There's a bit of class prejudice and a questioning of what a man is behind his proud public exterior.

    Most of the interest is quite simply in who's going to win the bet? A wager between two men in an exclusive club. The bet is that a very talkative man, Taylor (Franchot Tone) cannot keep silent for a year. His opponent, Tennyson is a fairly nasty sort, who resorts to taunting the hushed man with rumours of his wife being seen with young men while he's living in a glass partition in the club.

    Interesting enough, but there's nothing truly TZ about this one. It could have been an episode in a very different anthology series, much like 'The Jeopardy Room' (series five) could have been. Just a decent piece of TV story telling.
  • comment
    • Author: Shalinrad
    When we consider the price we will pay for the whole idea of honor, we can be viewed as some pretty stupid creatures. In this particular episode, a man wants so much to win that he pays the ultimate price. Of course, there is dishonor in the conclusion, but how can that repay what happens. This is the story of a man who gets fed up with a braggart and wants to shut him up. A bet ensues, and the rest is history. We all crawl inside as we view the pain and intense sacrifice presented here. But how do you cover such a bet. Does no one think? Does no have a moment of "what if"? This is a really unsettling episode, but quite memorable. I first saw it in high school and still remember every moment of it.
  • comment
    • Author: Jeb
    Franchot Tone, a man of wealth and breeding, dislikes Liam Sullivan, a man with no social background who talks constantly at the exclusive club to which they both belong. Fed up with Sullivan, Tone bets him that he can't keep his mouth shut for one year. The club will build a glasshouse with microphones in the game room. If Sullivan can stop yapping, after twelve months Tone will hand him a check for half a million dollars.

    In 1961, half a million would go a long way. Now, I'm sure that my dentist leaves that much in tips in a week, judging from what he charges me. I can't stand the smell of that dentist's office. I can't abide his voice either, especially when he shrieks out to his succulent dental assistant and mistress something like, "Prepare for an apicoectomy!" I don't even know what it is, and I'm paying through the mouth for it. They give you a balloon when you leave -- a half-million dollar balloon shaped like a Dachshund.

    Where was I? I wish you'd keep quiet and stop interrupting me for twelve months. Of course if you want to be locked up in a glass house for a year, that's up to you.

    Actually, I didn't mind it so much when Sullivan wound up incommunicado. I didn't like his voice much either. He looks a little like Vittorio Gassman but he sounds like a trained television-commerical voice-over artist. Franchot Tone brings his part off much better, although he's gotten pretty old and age has given his voice a slightly strangled sound at times, though that's nothing compared to what happens to Sullivan. I don't think I'll give the ending away.

    The story apparently owes a good deal to Chekhov's short story called "The Bet." That would account for the somewhat dated quality of the story -- all about breeding, will power, courage, and social class. These are the sorts of issues that Jay Gatsby grappled with. There's not much of that kind of grappling going on anymore. The Franchot Tones and the Tom Buchanans and the dentists live in great stone castles surrounded by moats and fully staffed with armed guards on the parapets.

    There's nothing supernatural about it; no violence or threat of violence; and the contest of wills is spelled out in just enough detail. It's superior in its subtlety. The kids might not get it but adults who pay attention will.
  • comment
    • Author: Love Me
    For a little peace and quiet to avoid the sound of his voice that disturbs the solemnity of the men's club that Franchot Tone belongs to, Tone offers him a million dollars if talkative Liam Sullivan stays silent for a year. Tone is arrogant old money and he considers Sullivan a bounder.

    Sullivan actually lives in a glass room for a year wired so that if he utters a word it will be recorded. Even the taunting of Tone to Sullivan doesn't break the silence.

    This is one of Rod Serling's best Twilight Zone episodes. In the end neither proves to have the best of character and both sacrifice considerably.
  • comment
    • Author: Helldor
    I remember how I was intrigued by this episode when I first saw it on TV at the age of 12. It had the classic twist at the end -- the "comeuppance" that I came to expect of great Twilight Zone episodes. But it also struck me as similar to a Chekhov short story I had read only a couple years earlier in my parent's library. So today, I checked the internet and found the short story online at www.online-literature.com/anton_chekhov/1255/. The Bet by Anton Chekhov - about a banker and a young lawyer who make a bet with each other about whether the death penalty is better or worse than life in prison. You can find it other places and on Wikipedia. Was this Twilight Zone episode inspired by the Chekhov short story? Don't know. Don't really care. In my humble opinion, both tales are fascinating; but the 30 min TV episode seems to be less compelling than Chekhov's very thoughtful excursion into the meaning of life. The former is very good TV; the latter is great literature. For fans of the Twilight Zone, I highly recommend reading The Bet by Anton Chekhov. It will take you less than 30 min.
  • comment
    • Author: Nuliax
    I don't know why, but I was fascinated by this episode as a kid. I wasn't able to figure out what the payoff would be, and when it came, I was horrified with the idea that someone would mutilate himself for any amount of money. Especially since I, a person of generally a few words, could take that bet and make a genuine run for it. Appropriately indexed for inflation of course.

    Hey, did you catch Tennyson's (Liam Sullivan) take on investing in the 'plastics' thing - a half dozen years before Dustin Hoffman got that advice in "The Graduate". I just had to chuckle over that one. But you know, considering Tennyson's money problems and his wife's predilection for spending big, how was he able to manage going unemployed for a year? Things like that weren't adequately addressed by Serling when he wrote these stories. I'm not sure if he could have glossed over those kinds of little details if he were doing them today.

    So it should be pretty evident who the biggest loser was here. Tennyson might have been left speechless, but it was the Colonel (Franchot Tone) who acted dishonorably. Backed into a corner when he knew he was going to lose, he attempted offering a piddling sum against a king's ransom to end the wager. When you go up against a thief and a scoundrel, it's best not to try and talk your way out of it.
  • comment
    • Author: Water
    A kinda of cool episode! Well I watched The Silence when I was a 14 years old. Years ago. These two club members have a spat about with the club big mouth. A bet is set! Be quiet for such and such time in a isolating chamber and get $200 000. Well it looks like the big mouth is about too win. Does this guy have a job!? Is it legal to live in a cubical like Big Brother? The Silence becomes bogged down! With day to day living. The bet is a no contest, and the dude who bet the big mouth doesn't have the money he's broke. In the ending the broke guy begs the big mouth to talk, Regrettably the big mouth is broke too and cut his vocal cords to win the bet. Big plot twist caught me off guard. The ending saves the episode. Six out of ten stars.
  • comment
    • Author: Reemiel
    When one first watches this episode, and sees all the old guys in the club, one assumes they are all filthy rich. So the one guy who is sitting there with his lawyer watching a young guy prattle on to others is preparing to offer him a wager. So you get the idea that the old rich guy, is respectable and been around for a while and the young talkative guy is a newcomer and then lawyer is kinda sympathetic to both but more so the younger guy but wont show it.

    So the older guy sends the butler, that great actor, i looked him up once, hes like real old and its 1961 here. he was one of those 1800's born people, hes like the only one i ve ever seen that doesn't freak me out a little and seems genuinely nice. I'm old enough to have met people born in the late 1800's when i was young and they were always such hard asses and frankly scary as hell. But i like the butler, Anyhow, for a whopping 500 grand (almost 4 million in our 2016 currency from what I'm reading, or if we are going with a ratio of what 100 dollars bought me in 2002 to compared to now, then 500 grand is 3.3 trillion in our time) he tells this guy, if he stays quiet for a whole year he will give him this money. So the guy agrees under the premise that he gets a prepaid check and the older guys like, no, you have my word, everyone here vouches for me. I was like "ut oh".

    So the guy goes into this room , with windows and microphones, and is too be quiet for a year. But think about it, its not just being monitored being quiet, you have to poop , pee , man scape, whip the doodle, what ever else you do, all monitored. But he is successful for like 8 months and the old guy freaks. he offers him a 1000 , then 5,000 and not being an idiot , the young guy is like "Screw that" but not in talking but writing, cause he 'd loose his bet. Then the old guy is like telling him his wife is planning to leave him and is with some guy and all that. The young guy is sweaty but does nothing.

    So it comes to the night where it is one year. Im questioning the trick ending to this episode. I figure the guy either made it so he cant talk surgically, some financial thing, or they do this trick on Criminal minds i once saw where they kept someone out of sunlight and changed the time a little each day so the bad guy didn't realize it was as early as it was . Turns out i missed out and saw the rich guy wasn't rich and couldn't pay the young guy cause he was a fraud. But then it turned out the young guy had a giant stitch gash on his neck from having his vocal cords trimmed, i was like "yuk" but then like "cool but then "oooh that's sad". no one won.
  • comment
    • Author: Westened
    This is one of the weirdest episodes of the show and you know why? Because it's completely normal! Yeah, this is one of only a handful of episodes with no supernatural or sci-fi stuff whatsoever. It's strange how uh, strange that can be. This episode features a guy betting another guy half a million dollars that he can't spend an entire year without talking. He's still allowed to write stuff down on pieces of paper.

    The best part is of course the ending. It ends up being a double twist! The guy reveals that he isn't rich and didn't even have half a million dollars in the first place. Then it's revealed the other guy cheated too! He had his vocal cords removed so he physically couldn't talk. For a normal episode, it's wonderfully written. ****
  • comment
    • Author: nadness
    Pompous Colonel Archie Taylor (a fine performance by Franchot Tone) and obnoxious chatterbox Jamie Tennyson (well played to the irritating hilt by Liam Sullivan) are both members of a private men's club. Taylor offers to pay Tennyson $500,000 dollars if he manages not to speak for one whole year.

    Director Boris Sagal keeps the compelling story moving along at a constant pace and builds a good deal of tension. Tone has a ball with his deliciously snarky dialogue and his character's cranky demeanor while Sullivan conveys a wealth of anguished emotions through his facial expressions alone. Jonathan Harris provides sturdy support as Taylor's no-nonsense lawyer George Alfred. Rod Serling's crafty script delivers a real doozy of a twist ending along with some stinging commentary on the perils of putting one's reputation on the line. The sharp black and white cinematography by George T. Clemens boasts several snazzy stylistic flourishes. A bang-up episode.
  • comment
    • Author: Thomeena
    This episode written by Rod Serling actually tung-in-cheek makes fun of the rich country club set. The area he went to school in, Binghamton, New York had elite pompous snobs and a country club. It was called the "Valley of Opportunity" but now that moniker is part of the areas past.

    Binghamton had the world largest shoe factory, a major film manufacturer, a world class company making flight simulators, the original home of IBM, Singer Sewing Machines, and so much more. In a way the main characters here remind me of that past. A man with a most annoying voice trys to win a bet of $500,000 dollars by remaining silent for a year. He cheat to do it, and cheaters never prosper. That's because at the end of the silent year, he finds out there is no money.

    So the two snobs that make this be both lose. It would be altogether fitting to note here, that these snobs in Binghamton have all gone, and a lot of the snob classes homes in the area are empty and decaying now. At the end of this one, so have the main characters.

    Zachery Smith (Jonathan Harris) from Lost in Space" guests here as the one person who is talking sense to everyone, but no one is listening.
  • comment
    • Author: Jazu
    Inferior TZ. Really plays more like an ironical Hitchcock episode than a TZ with its usual focus on the supernatural. Also reminds me of something de Maupassant the 19th century French ironist with his eye for the pretensions of the upper-crust would have composed. No need to repeat the plot here except to point out that it involves a highly unusual wager between two ostensible gentlemen at an exclusive gentlemen's club.

    Perhaps the most interesting feature lies in how Franchot Tone is photographed. Notice how artificially he's sometimes posed presenting only a right profile of his face. Mark Zicree in his helpful TZ companion guide points out that midway through filming , Tone suffered an injury to the left side of his face-- apparently one that could not be touched up. Hence, the artificial poses; and since screenplays are seldom filmed in chronological order, these odd profiles can turn up at any time. Anyway, I wish there were more to recommend in this static drawing-room drama with its rather tame outcome, but there really isn't.
  • comment
    • Author: Matty
    Where did he go to the bathroom? No shower either for a whole year? No change of clothes? He sure looked great for a guy filthy dirty, stinkin & holding his piss & mud for a year huh? I could go on but, get my drift? lame!!!!!!!1
  • Episode complete credited cast:
    Franchot Tone Franchot Tone - Col. Archie Taylor
    Liam Sullivan Liam Sullivan - Jamie Tennyson
    Cyril Delevanti Cyril Delevanti - Franklin
    Everett Glass Everett Glass - Club Member
    Felix Locher Felix Locher - Club Member
    John Holland John Holland - Club Member
    Jonathan Harris Jonathan Harris - George Alfred
    All rights reserved © 2017-2024 hd.thomson-multimedia.com