| Episode cast overview, first billed only: |
 | Tucker Carlson | - | Himself - Host |
 | Maxine Waters | - | Herself - California Congresswoman (archive footage) (as Rep. Maxine Waters) |
 | Adam Schiff | - | Himself - California Congressman (archive footage) |
 | Malcolm Nance | - | Himself - MSNBC Analyst (archive footage) |
 | Mollie Hemingway | - | Herself - The Federalist |
 | Robert S. Mueller III | - | Himself - Department of Justice Special Counsel (archive footage) (as Robert Mueller) |
 | Julian Epstein | - | Himself - Democratic Strategist |
 | Beto O'Rourke | - | Himself - Texas Congressman (archive footage) |
 | Don Lemon | - | Himself - CNN (archive footage) |
 | Kay Granger | - | Herself - Shutdown Negotiator |
 | Bob Menendez | - | Himself - New Jersey Senator (archive footage) |
 | Lisa Boothe | - | Herself - Independent Women's Voice |
 | Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez | - | Herself - New York Congresswoman (archive footage) |
 | Nicholas Giordano | - | Himself - Suffolk Community College Professor |
 | Tammy Bruce | - | Herself - Independent Women's Voice President |